Difference between revisions of "Earth system stabilisation"

From JModels
Jump to: navigation, search
 
(34 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
 +
[[Image:blue_marble.jpg|right|thumb|150px|Earth photographed in 1972 by the crew of the [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apollo_17 Apollo 17] mission.  It is sometimes known as the [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Marble ''Blue Marble''] photograph.]]
 
== '''Earth System Stabilisation''' ==
 
== '''Earth System Stabilisation''' ==
  
Line 6: Line 7:
 
Luck may have played a large role (c.f. [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthropic the Anthropic Principle]), as may have the incredible ability of evolution to adapt organisms to fit their environments. Some tenacious microbes may conceivably have persisted in out-of-the-way niches during environmental collapses, only to emerge and repopulate the rest of the planet afterwards.  This would help explain the ubiquity of DNA amongst all living organisms, as well as the similarity between living and ancient fossil [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stromatolites stromatolites].
 
Luck may have played a large role (c.f. [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthropic the Anthropic Principle]), as may have the incredible ability of evolution to adapt organisms to fit their environments. Some tenacious microbes may conceivably have persisted in out-of-the-way niches during environmental collapses, only to emerge and repopulate the rest of the planet afterwards.  This would help explain the ubiquity of DNA amongst all living organisms, as well as the similarity between living and ancient fossil [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stromatolites stromatolites].
  
 +
[[Image:scales.jpg|thumb|right|150px|Have stabilising feedbacks helped keep the Earth's environment in balance?]]
 
However, another possibility is that stabilising feedback processes intrinsic to the Earth System have helped to keep the planet's environment under control, and have opposed potentially fatal swings in environmental conditions.  
 
However, another possibility is that stabilising feedback processes intrinsic to the Earth System have helped to keep the planet's environment under control, and have opposed potentially fatal swings in environmental conditions.  
  
 
==Negative Feedback Mechanisms in the Models==
 
==Negative Feedback Mechanisms in the Models==
  
The Jmodels featured here allow insights into some of the automatic processes which may have kept the planetary environment in check. Five negative feedback processes are incorporated in the different models:
+
The Jmodels featured here exploration of some of the automatic processes which may have kept the planetary environment in check. Five negative feedback processes are incorporated in the different models:
  
 
(a) [[Feedback on Phosphate|'''phytoplankton growth and ocean phosphate''']]  
 
(a) [[Feedback on Phosphate|'''phytoplankton growth and ocean phosphate''']]  
Line 19: Line 21:
  
 
(d) [[Feedback on Saturation State|'''carbonate compensation and ocean carbonate''']]  
 
(d) [[Feedback on Saturation State|'''carbonate compensation and ocean carbonate''']]  
 +
<!-- (e) [[Feedback on Earth Temperature|'''Earth heat emission and Earth temperature''']] -->
  
(e) [[Feedback on Earth Temperature|'''Earth heat emission and Earth temperature''']]
+
==Using the JModels to Test their Effects on Stability==
 
 
==How to Test their Stabilising Influences==
 
  
 
The properties that these negative feedbacks endow on Earth System behaviour, and the degree to which they impart stability to the Earth environment can be analysed with the different models in several ways:
 
The properties that these negative feedbacks endow on Earth System behaviour, and the degree to which they impart stability to the Earth environment can be analysed with the different models in several ways:
  
(1) [[Random Starting Conditions|'''randomised initial conditions''']]
+
(1) [[Random Starting Conditions|'''Random initial conditions''']]
  
(2) [[Volcanic Emissions of Sulphur Dioxide|'''volcanic eruptions''']]  
+
<!-- (2) [[Volcanoes|'''Volcanic eruptions and global cooling''']]  -->
 +
(2) [[Comet Impacts|'''Comet simulations''']]  
  
(3) [[Comet Impacts|'''comet simulations''']]  
+
(3) [[Burning Fossil Fuels|'''Fossil fuel emissions of CO2''']]  
  
(4) [[Adding Extra Carbon Spread over Time|'''pulse addition experiments and fossil fuel scenarios''']]  
+
(4) [[Changing Nutrient Inputs Down Rivers|'''River inputs that change over time''']]
 +
<!-- (6) [[Faint Young Sun|'''Varying solar heating (Faint Young Sun)''']] -->
  
(5) [[Changing Nutrient Inputs Down Rivers|'''time-variable river inputs''']]
+
[[Image:Ideal feedback model.png|thumb|Figure 1: Ideal feedback model. The feedback is negative if B < 0, positive if B > 0|150px|right]]
  
(6) [[Faint Young Sun|'''time-variable solar heating''']]
+
==Positive as well as Negative Feedbacks==
  
 +
A note of caution: the models in this website focus only on negative, stabilising, feedbacks whereas we know that there are also many positive, destabilising feedbacks in the Earth System. The Earth System as a whole is less robust and more fragile than the impression given here. Possible positive feedbacks include, for instance, the postulated [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clathrate_gun Clathrate Gun Hypothesis]. A known positive feedback is the ice-albedo feedback whereby melting of snow and ice reveals dark ground or water underneath which absorbs more of the Sun's rays leading to yet further warming and ice melting. At the present time, this process is contributing to the [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polar_ice_packs#Extent_and_trends_of_polar_ice_packs| rapid melting of Arctic sea-ice]. The behaviour of the Earth System and the history of Earth climate emerges from both the negative and positive feedbacks. Although the focus here is on processes that aid stability, you should note that the Earth System also contains many processes that promote instability.
  
A note of caution: the models in this website focus only on negative, stabilising, feedbacks whereas we know that there are also many positive, destabilising feedbacks in the Earth System. The Earth System as a whole is less robust and more fragile than the impression given here. Possible positive feedbacks include, for instance, the postulated [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clathrate_gun Clathrate Gun Hypothesis] and the ice-albedo feedback whereby melting of snow reveals dark ground underneath which absorbs more of the Sun's rays leading to yet further warming and ice melting. The behaviour of the Earth System and the history of Earth climate emerges from both the negative and positive feedbacks. Although the focus here is on processes that aid stability, you should note that the Earth System also contains many processes that promote instability.
 
  
Taken altogether, these models give some insights into some different ways in which the Earth's environment may have been automatically, unconsciously, kept in balance. They may have contributed to the tenacity of life on Earth over the last few billion years.
+
Taken altogether, these models give some insights into some different ways in which the Earth's environment may have been automatically, unconsciously, kept in balance. They may have contributed in part to the persistence of life on Earth over the last few billion years.
  
 
==Further reading==
 
==Further reading==
Line 47: Line 50:
  
 
==External links==
 
==External links==
 +
* [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planetary_habitability Planetary habitability], [[Wikipedia]]
 +
* [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_life History of life on Earth], [[Wikipedia]]
 +
* [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_descent All life descended from one common ancestor], [[Wikipedia]]
 
* [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeostasis Homeostasis], [[Wikipedia]]
 
* [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeostasis Homeostasis], [[Wikipedia]]
 
* [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dynamic_equilibrium Dynamic Equilibrium], [[Wikipedia]]
 
* [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dynamic_equilibrium Dynamic Equilibrium], [[Wikipedia]]
* [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biogeochemistry Description of biogeochemistry], [[Wikipedia]]
 
* [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planetary_habitability Planetary habitability], [[Wikipedia]]
 
  
 
[[Category:Stabilisation]]
 
[[Category:Stabilisation]]

Latest revision as of 15:32, 24 August 2016

Earth photographed in 1972 by the crew of the Apollo 17 mission. It is sometimes known as the Blue Marble photograph.

Earth System Stabilisation

It is a remarkable fact that life on Earth has persisted in an unbroken chain for at least 2 or 3 billion years out of the 4.5 billion years of Earth's existence. It appears that the environmental conditions on Earth have never, not even once during this immense interval of time, become so unfavourable as to wipe out every trace of life. Given that all life requires liquid water and hence temperatures between 0° and 100°C (or thereabouts, depending on pressure, salinity, etc), this raises the interesting question as to how the planetary environment has been maintained in a habitable state for so long. Why is it that neither temperature nor any other critical environmental variable has ever in this time deviated so far from the biological comfort zone as to render the whole planet infertile?

Luck may have played a large role (c.f. the Anthropic Principle), as may have the incredible ability of evolution to adapt organisms to fit their environments. Some tenacious microbes may conceivably have persisted in out-of-the-way niches during environmental collapses, only to emerge and repopulate the rest of the planet afterwards. This would help explain the ubiquity of DNA amongst all living organisms, as well as the similarity between living and ancient fossil stromatolites.

Have stabilising feedbacks helped keep the Earth's environment in balance?

However, another possibility is that stabilising feedback processes intrinsic to the Earth System have helped to keep the planet's environment under control, and have opposed potentially fatal swings in environmental conditions.

Negative Feedback Mechanisms in the Models

The Jmodels featured here exploration of some of the automatic processes which may have kept the planetary environment in check. Five negative feedback processes are incorporated in the different models:

(a) phytoplankton growth and ocean phosphate

(b) nitrogen-fixer competitive success and ocean N:P ratio

(c) diatom competitive success and ocean silicate

(d) carbonate compensation and ocean carbonate

Using the JModels to Test their Effects on Stability

The properties that these negative feedbacks endow on Earth System behaviour, and the degree to which they impart stability to the Earth environment can be analysed with the different models in several ways:

(1) Random initial conditions

(2) Comet simulations

(3) Fossil fuel emissions of CO2

(4) River inputs that change over time

Figure 1: Ideal feedback model. The feedback is negative if B < 0, positive if B > 0

Positive as well as Negative Feedbacks

A note of caution: the models in this website focus only on negative, stabilising, feedbacks whereas we know that there are also many positive, destabilising feedbacks in the Earth System. The Earth System as a whole is less robust and more fragile than the impression given here. Possible positive feedbacks include, for instance, the postulated Clathrate Gun Hypothesis. A known positive feedback is the ice-albedo feedback whereby melting of snow and ice reveals dark ground or water underneath which absorbs more of the Sun's rays leading to yet further warming and ice melting. At the present time, this process is contributing to the rapid melting of Arctic sea-ice. The behaviour of the Earth System and the history of Earth climate emerges from both the negative and positive feedbacks. Although the focus here is on processes that aid stability, you should note that the Earth System also contains many processes that promote instability.


Taken altogether, these models give some insights into some different ways in which the Earth's environment may have been automatically, unconsciously, kept in balance. They may have contributed in part to the persistence of life on Earth over the last few billion years.

Further reading

  • L.R. Kump, J.F. Kasting & R.G. Crane (2003) The Earth System (2nd Edition), Prentice Hall.

External links